Woman buying a car

BUYING

Car Subscriptions VS Buying: What's Best for You?

In this article, we’ll cover:


  • An overview of car subscriptions and how they differ from buying or leasing a car.
  • The financial implications of both options, including costs like subscription fees and car loans.
  • The flexibility and convenience factors of car subscriptions compared to the traditional car-buying process.

Last Updated November 27, 2023

10 min read

In today's evolving automotive market, the traditional route of buying a car faces a modern competitor: car subscriptions. As consumers look for more flexible and convenient options, the debate of "car subscription vs buying" is becoming increasingly relevant. This comprehensive guide aims to explore the pros and cons of both options, helping you make an informed decision that suits your lifestyle and financial needs.

Understanding Car Subscriptions: A New Way to Drive


The Basics of Car Subscription Services


Car subscription services are a novel approach to automotive access, falling somewhere between leasing and renting a car. These services allow you to subscribe to a car for a period, typically with a monthly fee that covers not just the car but often includes insurance, registration, and maintenance costs. Unlike a car lease, subscription plans usually offer more flexibility with shorter-term commitments and the ability to switch cars.


How Car Subscriptions Stand Apart


One of the primary advantages of a car subscription is the all-inclusive nature of the monthly payment. This fee often covers insurance, maintenance, and in some cases, even fuel, providing a hassle-free experience. Additionally, subscription models allow for more frequent vehicle changes, which is a significant perk for those who enjoy driving different types of vehicles or have changing needs.

Buying a Car: The Traditional Route


The Financial Commitment of Buying a Car


When you buy a car, either through a full payment upfront or via a car loan, you're investing in a long-term asset. This process often involves a significant initial payment, followed by monthly payments if a loan is involved. Owning a car also means you're responsible for all additional costs, including insurance, registration, and maintenance, which can add up over time.


Long-Term Benefits and Drawbacks


Buying a car offers the advantage of ownership; once your car loan is paid off, the vehicle is yours, which can be financially beneficial in the long run. However, the disadvantage of car subscriptions and car ownership includes the depreciation of the vehicle and the responsibility for its upkeep. It's also less flexible than a subscription, as selling or changing vehicles requires more effort and time.

Analyzing Costs: Subscription Fees vs Car Loans


The Monthly Costs of Car Subscriptions


Car subscription plans require you to pay a monthly subscription fee, which can vary based on the car subscription company, the type of car, and the subscription model. This fee can sometimes be higher than the monthly payment of a car loan, but it includes most of the car-related expenses, offering a more comprehensive package.


Comparing to Car Loan Payments


In contrast, monthly payments for a car loan might be lower than subscription fees, but they don't cover additional expenses like insurance and maintenance. The overall cost of owning a car can be more when you add these additional expenses, making it crucial to consider the total cost of ownership when compared to subscription plans.

Flexibility and Convenience: Comparing Subscriptions and Buying


The Flexibility of Car Subscriptions


One of the biggest draws of car subscriptions is their inherent flexibility. These plans typically don't require long-term commitments, offering a level of freedom that traditional car buying or leasing can't match. For those who prefer not to be tied down by a long-term rental or a multi-year car loan, a subscription model can be an appealing option. This flexibility extends to the ability to change vehicles, which is especially beneficial for those who enjoy trying out different models or whose vehicle needs may vary throughout the year.


The Convenience Factor


In terms of convenience, car subscriptions often have the upper hand. Since the monthly subscription cost usually includes insurance, maintenance, and sometimes even roadside assistance, subscribers don't have to worry about these typical car-owning responsibilities. This can be a significant advantage for people who value a hassle-free experience and prefer not to deal with the logistics of car ownership.

Long-Term Considerations: Ownership vs Subscription


The Long-Term Financial Perspective of Buying


When it comes to long-term financial considerations, buying a car has potential benefits. Once your car loan is fully paid off, the car becomes an asset, despite its depreciated value. For those who plan to keep a car for many years, this can lead to cost savings over time, as you eliminate the need for monthly payments. Furthermore, owning a car provides the freedom to customize or sell the vehicle at your discretion.


Understanding the Subscription Model in the Long Run


Conversely, the long-term rental aspect of car subscriptions means you will always have a monthly payment as long as you're using the service. While this offers convenience and flexibility, it may not be the most cost-effective option in the long run, especially if you prefer to keep a vehicle for several years. Additionally, while you have access to a car, you never build equity in a specific vehicle, as you would with buying.

Making the Right Choice for Your Lifestyle


Choosing between a car subscription and buying a car ultimately depends on your lifestyle, financial situation, and personal preferences. Consider the pros and cons of each option:


  • Car Subscriptions: Ideal for those who value flexibility, variety, and convenience, and are comfortable with ongoing monthly expenses without the commitment to a single vehicle.
  • Buying a Car: More suitable for individuals looking for long-term financial benefits, the freedom to customize or sell, and those who don’t mind the responsibilities that come with car ownership.


It’s crucial to evaluate your driving habits, financial goals, and lifestyle needs. Whether you prioritize the latest models and a hassle-free experience or long-term financial savings and a sense of ownership, your decision should align with your overall life plans and financial strategy.


By carefully considering these factors, you can make an informed choice between the modern approach of car subscriptions and the traditional route of car ownership, ensuring that your decision fits seamlessly into your daily life and long-term aspirations.

Try a Roam Car Subscription today

Book your first car subscription in minutes and leave the burdens of traditional car ownership behind.

Sign up

Disclaimer: Roam is not affiliated with or endorsed by any automaker in any way. All product names, trademarks, and trade names are the property of their respective owners.

Disclaimer: Roam is not affiliated with or endorsed by any automaker in any way. All product names, trademarks, and trade names are the property of their respective owners.